Gunderson Denton & Peterson Logo Sized For Mobile Browsing

480-655-7440

Mesa AZ Business Lawyer
  • 1930 North Arboleda, Suite 201
    Mesa, AZ 85213
    480-655-7440
    40 N. Central Avenue, Suite 1400
    Phoenix, AZ 85004

  • Please leave this field empty.

  • Gunderson, Denton And Peterson Office Locations


    View View Gunderson, Denton And Peterson Locations in a larger map

    Legal Assistance With A Positive ROI

    Originally Published – LLC Publication Requirement – present and future
    THURSDAY, MAY 6, 2010

    LLC Publication Requirement – present and future

    Since 1994 New York has required LLCs (as well as LPs) to publish a notice of formation in two newspapers. New York is one of several states which imposes this extra step upon small companies who are already sensitive to startup costs (the publication costs can range widely from county to county from around $300 to over $1,600 in Manhattan). LLCs cannot avoid this requirement by forming their LLC in a foreign state; as soon as the LLC does business in New York, the publication requirement will be triggered. All publication filing fees go to the newspapers.

    How does a company satisfy this requirement? The LLC must contact the county clerk of the county where the LLC has its principal office. The county clerk will give the LLC the names of two newspapers in which the LLC must publish their notification within 120 days of formation.

    What happens if the LLC fails to publish within 120 days? The company will lose its authority to do business in New York State, which means that the LLC cannot sue anyone in New York courts and the Department of State will not issue a “good standing certificate” for the entity. Another serious consequence is the potential loss of limited liability protection. However, the LLC can still defend itself in the New York courts and its contracts are enforceable. There is no penalty for failing to publish or publishing late. Even if delayed, the publication will allow LLC to regain good standing.

    What is the purpose of this requirement? Theoretically, the publication aims to notify members of the general public who they are doing business with. However, in practice, it is hard to imagine that members of the general public regularly go through all the newspaper ads (especially in this Internet age when information about all companies registered in New York is freely available on the Department of Corporations website). Also, if forming an LLC in New York County, the New York Law Journal will likely be designated as one of the papers. The readers of the NYLJ are mainly lawyers, which displays the “irrationality” of the publication requirement being necessary to inform the general public who they are doing business with. Interestingly, the law does not require publications about a change in ownership or dissolution, even if such events happen shortly after the publication.

    What is the future of this publication requirement? The constitutionality of the law was unsuccessfully challenged in 2003 (See Barklee Realty v. Pataki, 309 A.D.2d 310 (2003), holding that (1) the statute did not violate plaintiffs’ limited right of access to New York courts, and that (2) the statute was rationally related to legitimate state interest in ensuring that limited liability companies actually made required disclosure, and thus, did not violate plaintiffs’ equal protection rights). The court noted that it was not their job to consider the wisdom or efficacy of that law or whether it is superior to other alternatives; rather, it is for the legislature alone to determine whether the statute was necessary.

    Recently, an interesting development has occurred in the legislature: Senator Lanza has introduced Bill S1101 eliminating publication requirements for LLC and LPs. On January 6, 2010, the Bill has been referred to the Committee on Corporations, Authorities and Commissions. It is unclear if and when the NY legislature will act on the proposal. Perhaps now is the good time for all the future LLC owners and members of the general public to let the legislators know their opinion about the publication requirement.

    Submitted From BusinessLawPost.com, for more on NYC business lawyer Arina Shulga check out her site.

    [jetpack-related-posts]

    Leave a Reply

    Meet Our
    Business Attorneys

  • Arizona Business and Franchise Lawyer Brad Denton
    Business Litigation Attorney
    business lawyers and real estate business attorneys
  • GDP Business Blog

    Business With Friends

    Deciding on a Business Structure

    A Rose by Any Other Name Might Not Smell as Sweet: The Process of Choosing and Protecting a Business Name

    Structuring Your Business Sale To Avoid An Unexpected Tax Hit

    Eight Questions to Help You Find the Target Market for Your Business

    Top Mistakes When Launching A Home-Based Business

    How to Plan Your Arizona Business Plan

    Business Startups: How to Pitch Your Idea to a Venture Capitalist

    Six Ingredients to Make Your Startup Business a Success

    Six Qualities to Look for in a Business Lawyer

    Three Steps to Choosing a Name for your New Business

    Seven Steps to Developing a Marketing Plan for Your Business

    How to Protect Your Intellectual Property

    Ways to Failure Proof Your Phoenix Business

    How To Convert An LLC To A Corporation In Arizona

    Does Your Startup Arizona Business Need a Patent?

    Non-Compete Agreements in the Sale of a Business

    Liability of Owners in Various Business Structures

    Small Businesses Feeling the Impact of the Government Shutdown

    Using a Letter of Intent to Reduce Risk in the Process of Purchasing a Business

    What Does it Take to Make a Binding Contract?

    Forming a Startup – Important Questions Co-Founders Should Ask First

    An Exit Plan for Your Business

    General Business Law at Gunderson, Denton & Peterson, P.C.

    Introduction to Gunderson, Denton & Peterson, P.C.

    How Business Owners Can Minimize The Cost Of Divorce

    The difference between a contract that falls under the UCC and one that does not and why it is important to you

    Problems with Decision-Making in an LLC

    Finance Options for Your Business

    Why Should Your Company Not Go Public?

    How do I buy an existing business?

    How Business Owners can avoid Personal Liability if others attempt to Pierce the Corporate Veil

    LLC Publication Requirement – present and future

    • Get Linkedin Mesa Arizona Lawyer
    • Legal counselors Facebook
    • Mesa Arizona Lawyer Twitter Account
    • law feed, legal advice, blogs and more
  • [toggles speed=500][toggle title="SITEMAP"][wp-blogroll showdesc=1 showbrk=1][/toggle][/toggles]
    contact@gundersondenton.com
    1930 North Arboleda, Suite 201
    Mesa, AZ 85213
  • Privacy Policy
    Design By Mesa Web Designer MFWD